When fractional is the right call
You have a founder making technical calls without a senior backstop, you need an architecture decision that will outlive the next two hires, and the bet is small enough that a full-time CTO would be over-leveraged. A fractional engagement is the cheapest way to put senior judgment on the org chart without committing to a hire that the company has not earned yet.
When interim is the right call
Your CTO just left, you are mid-fundraise, or you have a migration with a hard date. The shape is full-time hours, but the engagement ends at a defined milestone. Interim CTOs earn their fee by stabilizing the team, writing the spec for the next permanent hire, and making sure the migration ships before the deadline — not by setting a five-year thesis.
When full-time is the right call
You have raised a Series A or later, the engineering org is more than a handful of people, and you need a CTO who lives with the consequences of every roadmap call. The full-time hire is the right answer once the company can defend the cost and the headcount has actual people in it. Until then, fractional or interim is usually more honest.